Do we have a shortage of bandwidth or imagination? - Brooklyn


Apr. 30, 2014 8:45 am

Do we have a shortage of bandwidth or imagination?

Stanford's Dr. Andrea Goldsmith asks: Do we really have a crunch on our existing wireless systems or do providers just need to add new layers to it?

Checking out technology exhibits at the Brooklyn 5G Summit.

(Photo by Twitter user @nyupoly)

Do we really have a shortage of bandwidth? Or do network providers need to simply deploy more of the technology we already have available? That was the essence of the argument that Stanford‘s Dr. Andrea Goldsmith made in her fast paced keynote at the Brooklyn 5G Summit at NYU Engineering. One way providers could expand their capacity dramatically, she argues, is by increasing the number of cells in cellular networks.

Sponsored by NSN (a Nokia company) and NYU WIRELESS, the summit was an effort to get the top academics and industry leaders together to begin building a consensus about what the next generation of wireless will be and what standards should be agreed upon to make it work.

Dr. Goldsmith straddles those two identities. She’s a researcher who is well-regarded enough to earn one of the plum speaking spots at this first of its kind gathering but she’s also started her own companies.

Here’s a few of the more thought provoking points Dr. Goldsmith made during her Thursday talk:

  • ‘The Internet of Things’ movement aimed at connecting anything with a plug to the web will define 5G. We’ll see something like 50 billion sharing information through the cloud by 2020.
  • ‘Software Defined Networking’ is a critical new field where network hardware on the ground won’t hold its software locally, but draw on software in the cloud to run itself.
  • While many people are very happy with how far 4G LTE has come and see great potential still, Goldsmith said, “What we don’t have is good performance and high reliability.” That’s critical, for example, to better use phones as real sensors.
  • You often hear arguments that our existing networks are maxed out. In information theory, this is what’s known as “The Shannon Limit.” The truth is, though, Goldsmith argued, we don’t actually know yet what that Shannon Limit is.

Goldsmith argues especially strongly that providers are leaving a lot of bandwidth on the table by not building more cells within cells. The reason wireless networks are referred to as “cellular” is because they do really look like cell systems in biology. Areas are divided up into cells, defined by access point (usually a tower, but it doesn’t have to be). Users in different cells can use the same bandwidth, because each cell has access to the whole array of bandwidth.


So the smaller a cell is, the fewer people (or devices) will try to use a given slice of bandwidth.

5G millimeter wave technologies (like we’ve written about here) could make it a lot cheaper to build more cells within cells, without huge towers, to allow the existing network to go even further (and maybe eventually get the next generation of mobiles on an all new one).

Already a member? Sign in here


5 pitches from the Made in NY Media Center program turning creatives into founders

New York City to use streetlights as WiFi hotspots?

Blockchain solutions for the refugee crisis



You can win up to $360,000 at the WeWork Creator Awards


Terbium Labs

Technical Project Manager

Apply Now

In leaked memo, Trump admin considers building national 5G network

Meet Lunewave, an Urban-X company that’s making a new sensor for driverless cars

Can data make our cities better? Lessons from CARTO’s data conference



Explore how diverse teams build dynamic products with Dev Bootcamp

Sign-up for daily news updates from Brooklyn

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!