Philly tech vs. the Democratic machine - Philly


May 17, 2017 12:58 pm

Philly tech vs. the Democratic machine

How Rebecca Rhynhart's victory in Tuesday's primary shows the nascent power of the local tech scene.

Rebecca Rhynhart, Democratic nominee for City Controller.

(Courtesy photo)

At 9:49 p.m. last night, Rebecca Rhynhart tweeted to confirm what was already buzzing on social media: she had unseated three-time incumbent Alan Butkovitz as the Democrats’ nominee for City Controller.

“The Democratic machine is on its death bed, y’all,” tweeted Philly Mag’s senior reporter Holly Otterbein. In her article, Otterbein called the victory “yet another sign that the power of the city’s Democratic machine is waning.”

Congratulatory replies followed from a slew of Philly tech scenesters like data scientist and former City technologist Lauren Ancona, tech investor Brett Topche, Comcast’s Danielle Cohn and Jarvus developer Ben Novack.

The City’s former Chief Administrative Officer became a more visible face to the tech scene in May 2016, when a shakeup of the City’s tech staff structure put Chief Data Officer Tim Wisniewski and his team directly under her watch, following a turbulent couple of months under new city Chief Information Officer Charlie Brennan. Rhynhart’s office was a safe haven for the Wisniewski’s civic tech team to do their thing. (In her role as Chief Administrative Officer, Rhynhart did have oversight over the Office of Innovation and Technology, and thus Wisniewski’s team. The May 2016 shift removed a layer of bureaucracy.)

“This new structure elevates the prominence of the initiatives of open data and digital transformation,” Rhynhart said then. Prior to that position, which she held for just under a year before resigning to hit the campaign trail, Rhynhart spent six years as the City’s budget director. The Philadelphia Inquirer and The Daily News specifically mentioned that experience in their endorsements.


In those early days of the Kenney administration, as Brennan drew the ire of civic-minded technologists, Rhynhart positioned herself as someone who understood the importance of open data and that elusive concept of innovation. It was a savvy move, since the departure of Chief Innovation Officer Adel Ebeid had left the civic tech community hungry for a champion. In February, Northern Liberties web dev firm Jarvus, a convener for the civic tech set, hosted a meet and greet with the candidate. Jarvus cofounder Chris Alfano, also the cofounder of civic hacking group Code for Philly, was one of the local technologists and entrepreneurs who made it clear they were supporting the candidate.

(On the other hand, Rich Negrin, the city’s former managing director who was instrumental in hiring Ebeid and a vocal champion of innovation, among other things, was not able to ride said innovation wave to victory in the District Attorney’s race, despite some support from influential tech community members like Bob Moul and Raheem Ghouse.)

As a candidate, her campaign platform focused heavily on two tech-related issues: modernizing the methods used for audits and releasing open data  (Also, another very tech-y move: the campaign HQ was a Center City  MakeOffices location. She got a shoutout from the coworking space’s local Twitter account.)

We last saw Rhynhart in her CAO role back in October, joining Wisniewski in the PHL Innovation Lab as the duo presented the Beta version of the City’s website. She mentioned the final version (is there ever such a thing?) of the portal would be rolled out at some point during 2017. The event was an accurate final memento of the interaction between Rhynhart and the civic tech team: she was there supporting the initiatives and projects but allowed enough independence for the technologists to do their thing.

Rhynhart also won support from Code for Philly Executive Director Dawn McDougall. “It’s no secret that I was a big supporter, and Rebecca did a great job of engaging younger voters who her opponent had long overlooked,” McDougall said Wednesday. “She was connecting with urbanists in the city who could activate and mobilize an untapped group of voters.”

Code for Philly itself, though, remains neutral in terms of candidates. It is, after all, the local brigade of nonprofit Code for America, a 501(c)(3) national organization which declares its non-partisan status on its website.

“It’s important for us always to clarify when something is my personal position versus what is Code for Philly’s position,” McDougall said. “Often times, me making that statement doesn’t fully divorce my personal persona from Code for Philly in people’s minds. That said, part of why I support Rebecca is that she is aligned with many of the values we hold at Code for Philly. She cares about open data and government transparency, and she was a big supporter Code for Philly while she was the Chief Administrative Officer.”

The 42-year-old Rhynhart will face Republican nominee Mike Tomlinson on November. If she wins, which is likely, looks like tech will secure yet another ally in local government.

What to make of it all? This is the first time we’ve seen the civic tech community so actively organized around a candidate. We’re not trying to say that they’re the sole reason that Rhynhart won, but in a primary for a position that many people have never heard of, their voice undoubtedly counted. Rhynhart’s race shows that the tech community — at least one corner of it — is eager to throw their weight behind someone they believe in and perhaps more notably, it shows that the tech community has that weight to throw around.

We’ll be interested to see how Rhynhart’s supporters work with her going forward. Will we see her build a team of civic-minded technologists? Will the tech community keep tabs on her and hold her accountable to her campaign promises? And how does a community do that with a role like controller that’s not as constituent-facing as, say, City Council? We’ll keep you posted.

  • “This is the first time we’ve seen the civic tech community so actively organized around a candidate. ”

    This is completely inaccurate, and a bit insulting to the many people in the civic tech community who have been rallying around candidates (successfully or not) since at least 2005-2007. The tech scene was instrumental in Nutter’s against-the-machine win, for example, which was (holy moly I’m old!) 10 years ago. The broader tech community may have only recently started to gain more sway, but that’s just because the business tech scene is newer. Either way, there’s no question that the tech scene is wielding more power.

    • Juliana Reyes

      Thanks Alex – good point. You are catching our youthful ignorance over here. Say more about the tech scene’s role in electing Nutter? And who are we talking about specifically? I hadn’t actually heard much about that but eager to hear more.

      • Roberto Torres Luzardo

        Doubling down on Juliana’s comment here. We’d love to get your input. Also curious if you’ve seen such an, er, not-sexy office like that of the City Controller get this much attention from that broader business tech community.

      • So I can’t do an entire history of politics and the “tech scene” in the city, but the internet-enabled “Civic Tech” movement started nationwide in 2003/2004 around the Howard Dean & Wes Clark campaigns (see ). While these campaigns were short lived, they spawned a lot of national and local groups, as well as a lot of tech companies. I got involved in Drupal via Music for America (fka Dean for America), who were colocated with an org called CivicSpace (fka DeanSpace – ), and locally Philly for Dean became Philly for Change. It’s also interesting to note how many companies formed as a result of these early political efforts. Some that you may have heard of include SB Nation (sister site to Daily Kos), Mapbox (via Development Seed), Pantheon (via Chapter Three), Blue State Digital. And yes, even little ol’ Zivtech got its start from this movement. Even Drupal itself became a “thing” in the US because of the Dean movement ( )

        So why were the candidates so interested in (mostly younger) tech folks? Well, the Dean piece in Wired points to some:
        “The biggest news of the political season has been the tale of this small-state governor who, with the help of and hundreds of bloggers, has elbowed his way into serious contention for his party’s presidential nomination. As every alert citizen knows, Dean has used the Net to raise more money than any other Democratic candidate. He’s also used it to organize thousands of volunteers who go door-to-door, write personal letters to likely voters, host meetings, and distribute flyers.”

        And so, it should be no surprise to learn that Seth Williams’ initial campaign was led by Philly for Change’s Ray Murphy (also one of the main bloggers at Young Philly Politics) and that the then-outsider Nutter (who was disliked by most of the Dem machine) aggressively courted the tech scene. I’m pretty sure Nutter was at the Philadelphians Against Santorum party, another Ray Murphy campaign (where I also worked doing MySpace outreach and campus organizing), and he was definitely at the first YPP party ( ). Fun fact: the first guest blog post written on YPP after I moved it to Drupal ( – one of my first Drupal sites) was by Councilman Goode ( ) and then-Councilman Kenney was also a frequent participant ( ).

        Anyway, no shame in being too young to remember these things 😉 . The political/civic tech communities have certainly gained a lot more power, espescially as tech businesses and jobs have come to the forefront of everyone’s mind. The real news (imo) is that this election shows that the tech community is more aligned with a broader swath of Philly voters, who together have formed a bloc that is significantly more powerful than those old crumbums in the Philly Democratic City Committee.


Alfano, McDougall win seats on Code for America National Advisory Council

Two Philly candidates are vying for Code for America’s National Advisory Council. You know what to do

FixList eyes six-city expansion fueled by a $400K seed round



Vistar Media’s tech stack is not for the faint-of-heart

Center City, Philadelphia


Senior Business Analyst

Apply Now
Philadelphia, PA


Senior Data Engineer

Apply Now
Philadelphia, PA


UX Designer

Apply Now

Breaking: Charlie Brennan out as city CIO

Read this rundown of Philly’s civic-tech all-stars

Wanna run for office? Crowdpac wants to help you get funded



Grow your small business with Salesforce at this Jan. 10 event



Inside Sales Representative

Apply Now
Center City, Philadelphia


DevOps Engineer

Apply Now
Chesterbrook, PA


Enterprise Software Sales Representative

Apply Now

Sign-up for regular updates from

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!