Why city taxes should be no excuse for your startup in Philadelphia - Technical.ly Philly

Civic

Nov. 11, 2013 12:30 pm

Why city taxes should be no excuse for your startup in Philadelphia

Next time some entrepreneur tells you that she is starting her small business in another city or in the suburbs because of the taxes, tell her she must not know what she’s talking about.

Photo of Philadelphia City Hall by Rian Castillo in May 2009 via Flickr Creative Commons.

Updated 11/12/13 @ 11:30am: Made a clarification about which city tax was being discussed in point #2 of this article.

Next time some entrepreneur tells you that she is taking her small business to another city or to the suburbs because of the taxes, tell her she must not know what she’s talking about.

That’s because the impact that the burdensome City of Philadelphia tax structure has on startup businesses, particularly venture backed technology firms, is way overblown, said First Round Capital managing partner Josh Kopelman during ThinkFest this weekend. This is a place to start something, even if the later stage is something worth managing.

It’s something echoed by other business owners: for example, ecommerce company WebLinc has three buildings and more than 100 staff in Old City.

“Everyone complains about taxes, but if that’s what’s stopping you from building a business, you have a problem,” said WebLinc cofounder and CEO Darren Hill over coffee last week. “It could be better, but when it comes to talent and culture, you get something for being here.”

Think of it this way, as Kopelman described it during a Q&A session during the Philadelphia magazine event:

  1. The most criticized city-specific taxes are those for revenue and profits, which startup businesses traditionally have less of, as they develop a customer base. Even a bootstrapped product-first company that eschews venture funding will still likely have less profit in the beginning than later on.
  2. Nonetheless, the city’s revenue and profits tax structure is not far off from other cities like Chicago and New York, as we’ve reported before using PICA data. Update: To clarify, that doesn’t include the wage tax, which has been as much as double New York’s in recent years.
  3. The hated city wage tax is still kicking, but if you’re also offering employees company equity, either through shared ownership or in a traditional venture-backed employee incentive arrangement, those returns are taxed through the state’s capital gains tax, which is actually lower than the perceived startup business magnets of California or New York state.

Meanwhile, the standard cost of living and recruitment benefits are low, something that Curalate CEO Apu Gupta has frequently cited as a reason he’s building a company here. Despite the wage tax, things have gotten better for individual residents of the city too, as Pew has reported.

Advertisement

That’s not to say there isn’t a challenge in tax structure. Startups that grow to 15 or more employees are less likely to go to other regions, Kopelman has said, but as businesses grow their profits and size, that’s when a city begins competing with its outlying suburbs.

That’s one big reason why since 1970, Philadelphia has lost a quarter of its jobs while Boston, New York and D.C. have seen an increase in real jobs.

Companies in the city apply for tax credits — the state has spent $4.8 billion annually since 2007 — and there are calls for more in the technology sector. That’s why Councilman Bill Green has been working to update the city’s tax structure, though his focus has been on these young startups that might not be the most affected.

Others have pointed to the idea that simply better collecting what money the city is already owed could be a big boon. But whatever the case, the struggles are likely not a core issue for all young companies.

“Starting a business in Philadelphia makes a lot of sense,” Kopelman said. The challenge is keeping them.

-30-
VIEW COMMENTS

Advertisement

7 questions Philly startup founders want Mayor Kenney to answer

Building Philly’s own Amazon starts with fixing this city tax policy

Op-ed: Pa.’s ‘tech tax’ is the wrong type of disruption

SPONSORED

Philly

Vistar Media’s tech stack is not for the faint-of-heart

Philadelphia

Perpay

Product Designer

Apply Now
Philadelphia

Practice

Director of Sales

Apply Now
Center City, Philadelphia

IntegriChain

Senior Business Analyst

Apply Now

Councilman Oh, back at work, speaks up against the ‘Tech Tax’

Could the proposed Pa. tech tax threaten Philly’s status as a ‘lean startup’s paradise’?

Biggest year to date for Philly KIZ: 36 companies grab $2.4 million in tax credits

SPONSORED

Philly

Grow your small business with Salesforce at this Jan. 10 event

Philadelphia, PA

Linode

Senior Cloud Client Executive

Apply Now
Philadelphia

Practice (Instructure)

Senior Software Engineer

Apply Now
Philadelphia

Practice (Instructure)

Senior Software Engineer in Test

Apply Now

Sign-up for regular updates from Technical.ly

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!