Forget the Apple/FBI tiff: Delaware State Police have shady cell-tracking devices - Delaware


Feb. 23, 2016 7:19 am

Forget the Apple/FBI tiff: Delaware State Police have shady cell-tracking devices

Through FOIAs, The News Journal found Delaware State Police have paid a hefty sum for the Stingray — a secretive cellphone-tracking system that can sweep up large swaths of unsuspecting data.

By mimicking a cell tower, Stingrays scoop up criminal-finding phone data. Problem is, they scoop up your data too.

(Photo by Flickr user Marjan Lazarevski, used under a Creative Commons license)

In the midst of the Apple vs. FBI clash about releasing access to cellphone information, Delaware has been hit with its own phone-privacy (or lack thereof) bombshell: According to a story in The News Journal, the state police department possesses top-secret portable cell-tracking systems known as Stingrays.

Chris Williams, Delaware Agenda publisher (and Delaware contributor) wrote in his newsletter a brief explanation of how they work:

Your cell phone is often connected to multiple towers, and uses the one with the most powerful signal as the main tower. As you move, such as while in a car, the most powerful tower obviously changes. When that happens, a ‘handoff’ occurs, and your phone starts using the new tower. Also, some legitimate towers do not use encryption, and can instruct your phone to turn off encryption. So for a Stingray to work, all is has to do is A) be powerful, B) fraudulently identify itself, and C) turn off encryption.

Because they pretend to be a cell phone tower, Stingrays pull in information about everyone in the vicinity, not just the intended target.

Stingrays, generally located in police vehicles when in use, apparently collect telephone numbers, call history, text and location data, payment records and the numbers of incoming and outgoing calls and texts, but not the content of calls and texts.

It’s a story has covered extensively in Baltimore, which has been a hotbed of Stingray-related litigation.

The ACLU has found that at least 23 states have Stingrays, according to the paper. This map from Newsweek shows where, as of September 2014, known Stingrays have been in use. Note that Delaware is not highlighted.


Here's a map of Stingray states, as of September 2014.

Here’s a map of Stingray states, as of September 2014. Note: Clicking on a state won’t work here. (Image from Newsweek)

The News Journal wrote about several Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests it made about Stingray use in Delaware that were mostly denied, save for two documents.

One proved Stingrays are actually in state authorities’ hands: Records show the state paid Stingray producer Harris Corp. $949,704 between 2008 and 2014 for hardware, upgrades and training.

The other document was correspondence from 2012 between the Delaware State Police and the FBI, which said that no one outside of law enforcement could know any information about Stingrays. And, if information about a Stingray could be brought up in court, the police needed to make sure the case got dismissed.

That’s been the M.O. in Baltimore, according to a story from December 2014:

Authorities would even apparently rather lose in court than talk about the cell phone tracking. In a separate recent case, The Baltimore Sun reports that prosecutors withdrew important evidence that would have helped them win a robbery case because it would have required them to talk about the technology. When a judge asked police detective John L. Haley why he couldn’t talk about it, Haley cited a nondisclosure agreement with the FBI.

While warrants are necessary for Stingray use, The News Journal FOIA’d any warrants, but the state police said there were none.

Already a member? Sign in here


Hear from the privacy pros at Security by the Schuylkill

Pitch to speak at Comcast Labs Connect’s data security conference

How is the partial government shutdown affecting you?



Hear from the privacy pros at Security by the Schuylkill

Philadelphia, PA


Full-Stack Javascript Engineer

Apply Now

Technically Media Editorial Intern (Summer 2019)

Apply Now


Software Engineer

Apply Now

Understand the government’s tech ecosystem at this Philly conference

Philly’s Global Startup Accelerator is looking for Delaware startups too

New license? Share the news from the DMV’s new ‘Safe Selfie Zones’



Learn to lead digital transformation at Phorum 2019

Malvern, PA


Senior Front End Engineer – CX Journey Lab

Apply Now
Baltimore, MD 21201

14 West

Senior Software Engineer (Java + Apache Spark)

Apply Now

Sign-up for daily news updates from Delaware

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!