Civic News
Grow PA

Can ‘Jobs That Pay’ create jobs that grow?

Harrisburg economic development specialist Shaun Donovan believes the governor's proposed program should invest more in jobs training and healthcare apprenticeships.

Experts say Pennsylvania needs job growth in key sectors like healthcare. (GIF via YouTube via "Aerial View of Harrisburg, PA", Hamza Ahmad)

As we near the end of the fiscal year, two economic development components appear to have the most potential to be impacted by a new Pennsylvania state budget: An increase to minimum wage and the creation of job training programs, both of which Gov. Tom Wolf has focused on with his Jobs That Pay initiative.

The Jobs That Pay pledge is, in general, the governor’s frame for how he approaches the economy, said the governor’s press secretary J.J. Abbott.

“From the governor’s perspective, the value of job training programs, job and technology education … are obviously incredibly important for graduates and workers to get jobs to support their families,” he said. “But in reality, a lot of families are working full time and teetering on the poverty line.”

When asked if raising the minimum wage would benefit the individual employee at the expense of the small business, Abbott referred to what he called “the opposite end of that.”

“When [the governor] proposed the minimum wage, the Department of Revenue looked at the impact of that,” said Abbott.

Abbott said the Department of Revenue referenced more vying power for consumers and more disposable income in communities to buy products and services from small businesses. He also said this was proven true from a study conducted in Seattle, Wash., which showed not noticeable job losses but more money to spend.

“So,” he added, “positive impacts for small businesses.”

Shaun Donovan, economic development specialist for the Capital Region Economic Development Corporation (CREDC) in Harrisburg, said there is some confusion as to what Wolf has meant with his Jobs That Pay initiative but overall it is a good thing.

“At least it’s getting the conversation started,” said Donovan.

The problem Donovan sees is the desire for jobs that pay a living wage — about $12 an hour —  in exchange for no skill set.

“That’s not realistic,” he said. But he acknowledges that $8 an hour is also not a job that pays.

He said manual labor jobs, for example, don’t exist like they used to, which allowed people to get away with lower wages. Growing sectors, like technology, require a little bit more of a skill set.

For minimum pay, you expect minimum skill.

So, what is the solution?

Donovan’s thought: Access to education. This highlights a top concern Wolf has been trying to address with the creation of apprenticeship and job training programs.

“The poverty line is being defined by having a high school diploma,” he said. “What’s the problem we’re trying to solve? Poverty or quality of life?”

He said there is a challenge in some communities with varying levels of how people are willing to apply themselves. That then flows into pushback from employers as well.

“Only 4 percent of jobs pay minimum wage,” said Donovan. “For minimum pay, you expect minimum skill.”

Donovan said employers are willing to work with employees, though. For example, successions may be made, but perhaps the candidate can only be employed for four months without being enrolled in a basic education program. The potential workforce could then move from diploma to apprenticeship.

“Typically manufacturing and construction may be good places to start, but let’s get into healthcare. The top 10 jobs that have the most openings are in healthcare in middle to top [level] openings,” said Donovan. “Job apprenticeships could potentially help. Take semi-skilled workers and move them up the chain a little bit. CNAs to RNs, for example. Definitively paint a pathway.”

He explained that minimum wage jobs are not positioned to be permanent in our economy as much as it can be helped.

“Those jobs shouldn’t be the end of your line,” said Donovan.

This story is part of Grow PA, a reported series on economic development across 10 Pennsylvania counties underwritten by the Chamber of Commerce for Greater Philadelphia. Sign up for our weekly curated email here.

Before you go...

Please consider supporting Technical.ly to keep our independent journalism strong. Unlike most business-focused media outlets, we don’t have a paywall. Instead, we count on your personal and organizational support.

3 ways to support our work:
  • Contribute to the Journalism Fund. Charitable giving ensures our information remains free and accessible for residents to discover workforce programs and entrepreneurship pathways. This includes philanthropic grants and individual tax-deductible donations from readers like you.
  • Use our Preferred Partners. Our directory of vetted providers offers high-quality recommendations for services our readers need, and each referral supports our journalism.
  • Use our services. If you need entrepreneurs and tech leaders to buy your services, are seeking technologists to hire or want more professionals to know about your ecosystem, Technical.ly has the biggest and most engaged audience in the mid-Atlantic. We help companies tell their stories and answer big questions to meet and serve our community.
The journalism fund Preferred partners Our services
Engagement

Join our growing Slack community

Join 5,000 tech professionals and entrepreneurs in our community Slack today!

Trending

Trump may kill the CHIPS and Science Act. Here’s what that means for your community.

Election results: Live updates on presidential, Senate, House and PA races

Technical issues at the polls hit Pennsylvania, county extends voting hours

14 tech community events to be thankful for in November

Technically Media